On Using Politics to Address Morality

I’m an early Never Trumper, roughly the same age as Sarah Longwell, and a huge fan and early supporter of The Bulwark. One of my favorite podcasts is Sarah’s Focus Group because it’s precisely the sort of grounded approach to understanding what’s going on that I think is essential. But in the spirit of being more critical of the things you like than the things that are just obviously stupid, I have a problem with the latest episode.

Conversations like this, while well intentioned, never satisfy me because they always bake in the assumption that Trump is only or primarily a political decision. I disagree.

I think Trump is overwhelmingly posing a moral question. Assume for a moment that Trump was actually right about the basic policy issues involved. (Hard to do, I know.) Are his proposed solutions morally justifiable? No! Does he demonstrate understanding of the moral implications of his actions? No! Should we want a leader who promises prosperity by any means necessary? No!

Just as war is politics by other means, politics is morality by other means. Conversations about how to win a political debate are like conversations about how to win a war. Important when necessary, but these conversations often miss the fact that it never should have come to this in the first place. The problem with war is that it often represents a profound failure of politics. In the same way, political debates often represent a profound failure of morality.

I don’t think you can avoid war by becoming a better warrior, and I don’t think you can solve moral problems by treating them as political issues up for debate.